Tuesday, February 18, 2003
previous entry | main | next entry | TrackBack (0)
AN ODD INTERVIEW: David Adesnik
AN ODD INTERVIEW: David Adesnik over at OxBlog highlights something that's been bothering me as well -- the recent Sunday NYT Magazine interview with Robert Kagan. More than a third of the questions dealt with whether Kagan was a "chicken hawk." What's weird about this is Kagan's answer to the first question on this point:
"Did you serve in the military?
I was 14 when the Vietnam War ended, and I didn't choose the military as my career path."
That really should have ended the questioning on this topic, but the interviewer persisted for three more questions.
I vehemently disagree with the chicken hawk logic, but I can sort of understand the point being made about elites avoiding military service during Vietnam. The thing is, once the military switched to an all-volunteer force, the question becomes somewhat moot -- either you chose the military as a career or you did not. Kagan did nothing dishonorable or duplicitous -- and yet he has to explain why we shouldn't be living in a Starship Troopers-kind of society.posted by Dan on 02.18.03 at 02:39 PM