Wednesday, March 30, 2005

previous entry | main | next entry | TrackBack (0)


As the Sciavo commentary descends into silliness....

In recent decades, the appearance of Jesse Jackson has been a useful leading indicator of a political issue degenerating into complete silliness.

In this case, however, the conclusive signal about the sheer idiocy of most of the Schiavo commentary comes from today's Chicago Tribune op-ed page. In it, David Martin publishes his living will, which includes the following:

I want it to be known that I fear degradation, indignity and political hypocrisy far more than death. I ask my medical attendants to bear this in mind when considering what my intentions would be in any uncertain situation.

If the time comes when I can no longer communicate, this declaration shall be taken as a testament to my wishes regarding medical care. If it is the opinion of two independent doctors who are not U.S. senators that there is no reasonable prospect of my recovery from severe physical illness, or from impairment expected to cause me severe distress or render me incapable of rational existence, then I direct that I be allowed to die and not be kept alive by artificial means such as life-support systems, tube feeding, resuscitation or hastily passed, politically motivated federal legislation....

I wish the following persons to be avoided at all costs in the event of uncertainty about my wishes:

Dr. Bill Frist, U.S. Senate, Washington

Tom DeLay, House of Representatives, Washington

George W. Bush, the White House, Washington

OK, this is pretty much the kind of thing I predicted would happen, but let's skip that.

What got me was Martin's byline: "David Martin is a lawyer who lives in Ottawa, Canada."

Now, whilethe U.S., Canada, and Mexico have recently pledged greater security and economic integration, I'm still pretty sure that no one living in Ottawa, Canada really has to worry about a Schiavo-type scenario happening.

[C'mon, wasn't Martin just being a smart-ass -- a type of behavior with which you're familiar?--ed. Yes, but to be a good smart-ass one must have the comedy equivalent of legal standing -- and Martin doesn't.]

posted by Dan on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM




Comments:

You have to expect some addled behavior from Canadians until NHL settles its labor problems.

posted by: Zathras on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



It is always a bit frightening when life begins to resemble the movies. It is even more frightening when it begins to resemble this one.

posted by: Appalled Moderate on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



Canadians like to vacation in Florida, so there is always the possibility he could be there when the Big One hits.

Cranky

posted by: Cranky Observer on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



The best version of the "living will" I've see so far is this one.

posted by: Nicholas Whyte on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



You know the Canadian inferiority complex can get no worse, when . . .

You lose any sense that there is a Canada.

Patrick

posted by: PD Shaw on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



Well, remember we were abolishing Canada's sovereignty a few weeks ago, so they're just being careful.

posted by: Anderson on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



Oh those poor, poor Americans. First they can't even do an occupation of a third world country right, and now they have to endure snarky Canadians writing snarky articles about them.

posted by: Oscar on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



Is he assuming that Frist, DeLay and Bush would want him alive?

posted by: Herb on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



Um, Dan?

Is he Canadian, or an American expat?

If the latter, he can move back at any time. And, knowing this batch of GOP, they probably could come up with some way of meddling with an expatriate in a vegetative state, if they thought it'd be politically advantageous.

posted by: Jon H on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



Yeah, good point about the comedy equivalent of standing. Since no American ever mocks any other nation, the citizens of the world should reciprocate. I understand it's part of the Warsaw Convention. . .


posted by: arthur on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



Dan's only mad because virtually ANY doctor in Canada is better than cat killer Frist.

posted by: weinerdog43 on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



"Yeah, good point about the comedy equivalent of standing. Since no American ever mocks any other nation, the citizens of the world should reciprocate. I understand it's part of the Warsaw Convention. . ."

Quiet, Frenchie.

posted by: Jim Dandy on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



I thought Bush's next target in the "War on Terrorism" was Canada?

posted by: flaime on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



Perhaps after watching Paul Martin stacking the Senate, that would be a legit concern.... Didn't they do that in Germany a few years ago?

posted by: Bithead on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



There is another possibility: this David Martin could be the same David Martin that had a column with the same Chicago Tribune back in the 1980's. That Martin's beat was the Pentagon and wrote a twice-weekly column on defense and security matters.

I think there was some difference of opinion between the writer and management, leading to his departure.

But it is quite common for the Chicago papers, especially the Trib, to pick up former writers/reporters from other outlets in the Chicago market after there welcome had been worn out.

So you all may not have to read in to this as much as you are.

posted by: Anon. And on. on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]



Now, whilethe [sic] U.S., Canada, and Mexico have recently pledged greater security and economic integration, I'm still pretty sure that no one living in Ottawa, Canada really has to worry about a Schiavo-type scenario happening.

Uh, why? I've lived in Canada for many years. It most certainly could happen - there is no limit to the stupidity and moral bankruptcy of mny politicians, everywhere.

posted by: rt on 03.30.05 at 10:15 AM [permalink]






Post a Comment:

Name:


Email Address:


URL:




Comments:


Remember your info?